There were basically two qualifications for making the team: Statistics and Fame. There are many great Yankees statistically, who are lost in time and fail to live up to the title of a "Legend". The team was mostly decided based on statistics while a Yankee, but other players were added to the team due to their notoriety despite not having overly-significant Yankee stats.
The Team
- Batters are followed by their years with the Yankees, Average, Homers, RBI, and Hits as Yankees
- Pitchers are followed by their years with the Yankees, Wins, Era, and strikeouts as Yankees Saves are noted for relief pitchers.
- Bold indicates Hall of Famer, Italicized are Hall of Famers as Yankees
- #X indicates number is retired
- C indicates a captain of the Yankees
- SS-Derek Jeter (15+) .316, 215, 1032, 2624. C
- CF-Joe Dimaggio (13) .325, 361, 1537, 2214. #5
- RF-Babe Ruth (15) .349, 659, 1975, 2518. C, #3
- 1B-Lou Gehrig (17) .340, 493, 1995, 2721. C, #4
- LF-Mickey Mantle (18) .298, 536, 1509, 2415. #7
- 3B-Alex Rodriguez (6+) .299, 219, 653, 905
- DH-Reggie Jackson (5) .281, 144, 461, 661. #44
- C-Yogi Berra (18) .285, 358, 1430, 2148. #8
- 2B-Joe Gordon (7) .271, 153, 617, 1000
- 3B-Tony Lazzeri (12) .293, 169, 1154, 1784
- OF-Bernie Williams (16) .297, 287, 1257, 2336
- OF-Dave Winfield (9) .290, 205, 818, 1300
- SS-Phil Rizzuto (13) .273, 38, 563, 1588. #10
- C-Bill Dickey (17) .313, 202, 1209, 1969. #8
- 1B-Don Mattingly (14) .307, 222, 1099, 2153. C. #23
- Whitey Ford (16) 236, 1956, 2.75. #16
- Red Ruffing (15) 231, 1526, 3.47
- Lefty Gomez (13) 189, 1468, 3.34
- Ron Guidry (14) 170, 1778, 3.29. C. #49
- Catfish Hunter (5) 63, 492, 3.58
- Long Relief-Mel Stottlemyre (11) 164, 1257, 2.97
- Set Up-Goose Gossage (7) 42, 512, 2.14, 151 sv
- Sparky Lyle (7) 57, 454, 2.14, 141 sv
- Dave Righetti (11) 74, 940, 3.11, 224 sv
- Closer-Mariano Rivera (15+) 69, 973, 2.30, 500 sv
Just Missed
- OF-Earle Combs (12) .325, 58, 632, 1866
- OF-Rickey Henderson (7) .288, 78, 255, 663
- C-Thurman Munson (11) .292, 113, 791, 1558. C. #15
- C-Elston Howard (13) .279, 161, 733, 1405. #32
- 2B-Willie Randolph (13) .275, 48, 549, 1731. C
- SP-Allie Reynolds (8) 131, 967, 3.30
- SP-Andy Pettitte (12+) 185, 1635, 4.02
- SP-Mike Mussina (8) 123, 1278, 3.88
- SP-Roger Clemens (6) 83, 1014, 4.01
Worth Noting
- 3B-Graig Nettles (11) .253, 250, 834, 1396. C
- 1B-Johnny Mize (5) .299, 157, 505, 733
- C-Jorge Posade (15+) .277, 231, 916, 1422
- SP-Jack Chesbro (7) 128, 913, 2.58
Future members?
- 2B- Robinson Cano
- C-Jorge Posada
- SP-CC Sabathia
- 1B-Mark Teixiera